I bought this to go on top of a bench for my husband. I looked through a LOT of them to compare. (Even read a ton of reviews)This one arrived quickly, and was packaged well. It was shipped in a vacuum sealed plastic bag and looked wafer thin, until I opened the bag.It did puff up fairly quickly, but filled in more during the night.I bought the red one. The color is vibrant, and the fill is just perfect! Nice and full, without being lumpy or too firm. (But your butt definitely doesn't bump the bottom, either)I may be buying another one, for a different bench I bought. (Right now I'm using that bench in an entryway. To remove shoes and set things on so I don't forget the next day... )If I do buy a cushion, it will definitely be from this vendor, and this same style.You won't be disappointed.